Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Menachem Berkowitz's avatar

So interesting…

R Boruch Sholom (b. haTzemach Tzedek)’s son R Levi Yitzchok of Podobranka had 3 sons. (A daughter “צ״ז” is mentioned exclusively in Reshimos Rabash).

The 3 sons were R Boruch Shneur, R Avrohom & R Menachem Mendel.

It seems that R Avrohom has no living descendants, as his son Levik (“דער קליינער”) had two children, Avrohom & Margolia. Avrohom went missing in WWII, and Margolia never married, as you say.

R Boruch Shneur has two living lines of descent, as follows:

He had 4 children — R Levik, R Shmuel, R Sholom Shlomo & Rada Sima.

R Levik had 3 sons (the Rebbe, Dovber & YAL), of which only Yisroel Aryeh Leib had children — Dalia (Rothman), who has 2 sons, Aryeh & Daniel Yehoshua. I’m assuming that at least one of the two boys has a family, which is one line of descent of R Boruch Shneur.

R Shmuel had one son, Menachem Mendel, who had one son, Menachem Mendel “Eduard”, who evidently had children. This is the other living line of descent from RBS.

R Sholom Shlomo (who married Rochel, daughter of Radatz Chein) had one daughter, Zelda Schneerson-Mishkovsky, who married but had no children.

And lastly, I couldn’t find any information on Rada Sima, including her husband, whose last name was evidently “קאזאצקוב”. Nothing on Geni, Chabadpedia, etc.

So R Avrohom: 1 son (Levik), who had 1 son (Avrohom) & 1 daughter (Margolia), neither of which had kids. (Maybe R Avrohom had more kids than just Levik? Idk anything about him)

R Boruch Shneur: 3 sons (R Levik, Shmuel, Sholom Shlomo) & 1 daughter (Rada Sima), btwn which were 5 grandkids (the Rebbe, Dovber, YAL, MM and Zelda), of which 2 had kids (YAL had Dalia, MM had MM/Eduard).

The other son of R LY of Podobranka was R Menachem Mendel, much of whose family *you’ve* discovered (I really, really appreciate all of your work!!!! Not just on this subject).

R MM had 5 children:

- Boruch Sholom “Boris”

- Shneur Zalman

- Yehudis Butman

- Freida Eber

- Genia/Evgenia

- Boris had 2 children: Yaakov & Rosa

- Shneur Zalman had 2 children: Hadassah Carlebach & Sholom Ber

- Yehudis had 4 children: Leah Kahn, Sholom Ber, Shmuel MM “Mule” & Merele Swerdlov

- Freida had 2 children: Avrohom Elya & Leah Henia, who murdered together with her & R Yehuda Eber in Riga

- Genia had 1 son: Leonid

So MM had 11 grandchildren from 5 children, 9 of which survived to adulthood, (unless there are more to be discover from Boris or Genia).

That isn’t a big family considering normal trends in Orthodox/Chassidic families, but *far* outpouces R Boruch Shneur & Avrohom.

Why I wrote this? Idk. I guess I just wanted to get it down “on paper”

Expand full comment
Menachem Berkowitz's avatar

Thinking aloud here…

Is it possible the paragraph beginning “My grandfather” was written by *Levik* in some arrest document, and Margolia is quoting it?

I.e. “My grandfather” refers to R LY of Podobranka, who died at 44 years old, and “my father” refers to R Avrohom?

It’s improbably given the format of the post, but maybe?

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts