Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Zalman AlpertHi's avatar

Speaking of pictures.

The Rebbe spent at least 13 years in France and Germany,yet all we have are a few pictures either about his wedding time or 2with this father in law.

Are we expected to believe no pictures exist all thos years?

Interesting no pictures with other people,why was he a recluse we even have photos or Rav Yoel of Satmar with his wife

Maharash picture would be most interesting but 20 more pictures of Rebbe

from 1929-1942 would tell us more about Rebbe than all the so called biographies by Telushkin,Deutsch,Oberlaender.Heilman,Steinsaltz and others.

Alas they will never see the light of day

Expand full comment
Zalman AlpertHi's avatar

Given the cult of personality that has dominated Chabad since at least 1992,the Schneerson family plays no role in Chabad.

The Rashags apt was eliminated from the face of the earth.

In Chabad histories people like Rabbi Shilom Ber Gourary are well non people.

There are no Chabad schools etc named for either R Moshe Horrnstein or his son Rabbi MM Horrnstein.

Not to speak about others.

Of course a select few are still interested in Schneerson family but as an academic subject but not as part of the Chassidus ,as yorzaits are not marked

As in post 1918 Russia there is a new nobility Krinsky,Shemtovs ,Cunin,Herson etc

So few care about Schneerson family with a hat or without a hat.

It's all about 1person as we say Eyn od milvado

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts